Skip to main content

Table 4 Predictive performance comparison of bowel and VAT-bowel radiomics models in differentiating PNR from PR in the training and validation cohorts

From: CT-based radiomics signature of visceral adipose tissue and bowel lesions for identifying patients with Crohn’s disease resistant to infliximab

Variable

DeLong’s test

McNemar’s test

Hosmer-Lemeshow test

IDI

AUC (95% CI)

Pa

Accuracy (95% CI)

Pb

χ2

Pc

Index (95% CI)

Pd

Training cohort (PNR/PR = 33/79)

 Bowel radiomics model

0.832 (0.750–0.896)

0.165

0.732 (0.643–0.805)

0.076

11.056

0.199

0.031 (0.006–0.056)

0.016

 VAT-bowel radiomics model

0.873 (0.797–0.928)

0.821 (0.740–0.881)

5.668

0.684

Internal validation cohort (PNR/PR = 14/34)

 Bowel radiomics model

0.784 (0.641–0.889)

0.098

0.708 (0.568–0.818)

0.070

5.850

0.664

0.042 (0.005–0.078)

0.024

 VAT-bowel radiomics model

0.840 (0.706–0.930)

0.813 (0.681–0.898)

10.08

0.259

External validation cohort (PNR/PR = 22/49)

 Bowel radiomics model

0.799 (0.687–0.885)

0.376

0.690 (0.575–0.786)

0.035

9.139

0.331

0.037 (0.003–0.070)

0.032

 VAT-bowel radiomics model

0.833 (0.726–0.911)

0.817 (0.711–0.890)

7.262

0.509

  1. PNR primary nonresponse to infliximab therapy, PR response to infliximab therapy. Bowel radiomics model, radiomics model based on the features extracted from the whole inflamed bowel; VAT-bowel radiomics model, radiomics model based on the features extracted from both visceral adipose tissue and the whole inflamed bowel. AUC, area under ROC curve; CI, confidence interval; IDI, integrated discriminant improvement. ap value is the significance level of the comparison of AUC between the bowel and VAT-bowel radiomics models according to DeLong’s test. bp value is the significance level of the comparison of accuracy between bowel and VAT-bowel radiomics models according to McNemar’s test. cp value is the significance level of the difference between the prediction probability and the true value for each model according to Hosmer-Lemeshow test. dp value is the significance level of the improvement (IDI > 0) in predictive performance of the new model (VAT-bowel model) over the old model (bowel model)