Table 2 Characteristics of the papers dealing with soft-tissue sarcomas included in the systematic review
First author | Year | Aim | Tumor | Design | Reference standard | Modality | Database size (n) | Public data | Segmentation | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Process | Style | |||||||||
Corino [52] | 2018 | Grading | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 19 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [39] | 2020 | Metastatic relapse Survival | Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology Follow-up | MRI | 35 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [42] | 2020 | Metastatic relapse Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology Follow-up | MRI | 50 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [30] | 2019 | Therapy response | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Prospective | Histology Imaging | MRI | 25 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [47] | 2019 | Therapy response | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 65 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [63] | 2020 | Therapy response Survival | Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology Follow-up | MRI | 21 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [36] | 2020 | Therapy response Survival | Desmoid tumor | Retrospective | Imaging Follow-up | MRI | 42 | No | Manual | 3D |
Crombé [31] | 2020 | Metastatic relapse Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology Follow-up | MRI | 70 | No | Manual | 3D |
Gao [33] | 2020 | Therapy response | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Prospective | Histology | MRI | 30 | No | Manual | 3D |
Hayano [21] | 2015 | Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Prospective | Follow-up | CT | 20 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Hong [64] | 2020 | Grading | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 42 | No | Manual | 3D |
Juntu [48] | 2010 | Benign versus malignant | Multiple benign/ malignant histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 135 | No | Manual | 2D with MS |
Kim [65] | 2017 | Benign versus malignant | Multiple benign/ malignant histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 40 | No | Manual | 3D |
Leporq [19] | 2020 | Benign versus malignant | Lipoma Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 81 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Malinauskaite [23] | 2020 | Benign versus malignant | Lipoma Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 38 | No | Semiautomatic | 3D |
Martin-Carreras [34] | 2019 | Benign versus malignant | Myxoma Myxofibrosarcoma | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 56 | No | Manual | 3D |
Mayerhoefer [57] | 2008 | Benign versus malignant | Multiple benign/ malignant histotypes Non-tumoral lesions | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 58 | No | Manual | 2D with MS |
Meyer [66] | 2019 | Proliferation index | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 29 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Peeken [25] | 2019 | Grading Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology Follow-up | MRI | 225 | No | Manual | 3D |
Peeken [27] | 2019 | Grading Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology Follow-up | CT | 221 | Yes | Manual | 3D |
Pressney [14] | 2020 | Benign versus malignant | Lipoma Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 60 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Spraker [51] | 2019 | Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Follow-up | MRI | 226 | No | Manual | 3D |
Tagliafico [26] | 2019 | Local relapse | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Prospective | Histology Imaging | MRI | 19 | No | Manual | 2D with MS |
Thornhill [49] | 2014 | Benign versus malignant | Lipoma Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 44 | No | Semiautomatic | 3D |
Tian [35] | 2020 | Metastatic relapse | n/a | Retrospective | Histology Imaging | MRI | 77 | No | Manual | 3D |
Tian [67] | 2015 | Therapy response Survival | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Prospective | Histology Follow-up | CT | 20 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Timbergen [20] | 2020 | Histotype | Desmoid tumor Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 203 | No | Manual | 3D |
Vallières [55] | 2015 | Metastatic relapse | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology Imaging | MRI | 51 | Yes | Manual | 3D |
Vallières [68] | 2017 | Metastatic relapse | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology Imaging | MRI | 30 | Yes | Manual | 3D |
Vos [40] | 2019 | Benign versus malignant | Lipoma Liposarcoma | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 116 | No | Semiautomatic | 3D |
Wang [41] | 2020 | Grading | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 113 | No | Manual | 3D |
Wang [43] | 2020 | Benign versus malignant | Multiple benign/ malignant histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 206 | No | Manual | 3D |
Wang [24] | 2020 | Benign versus malignant | Multiple benign/ malignant histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 91 | No | Manual | 3D |
Wu [18] | 2020 | Benign versus malignant | Multiple benign/ malignant histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | CT | 49 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Xiang [17] | 2019 | Grading | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 67 | No | Manual | 2D without MS |
Xu [37] | 2020 | Grading | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 105 | No | Manual | 3D |
Zhang [44] | 2019 | Grading | Multiple sarcoma histotypes | Retrospective | Histology | MRI | 37 | No | Manual | 3D |